A Dynamic and Multilayered Examination of Comment Networks in a Crowdsourcing Challenge Community

ORCID

Yiqi Li: 0000-0002-3730-5743

Document Type

Article

Date

2025

Keywords

crowdsourcing challenge, social network dynamics, comments, network multiplexity, ideation

Language

English

Acknowledgements

Acknowledgment. We would like to express our gratitude for the valuable and insightful feedback from Dr. Peter Monge, Dr. Janet Fulk, Dr. Aimei Yang, Dr. Kevin Crowston, Dr. Raj Dewan, anonymous reviewers, and track editors. Their expertise and guidance have been invaluable to the growth of this project.

Disciplines

Communication Technology and New Media | Organizational Communication

Description/Abstract

This study examines how participants of crowdsourcing challenges (ideators) provide comments to one another under the dual community forces of collaboration and competition. Content analysis reveals comment types with various degrees of cooperativeness and self- interestedness. Based on comment-sending patterns, clustering analysis unveils ideators’ different roles in the communities: endorsers, self-promoters, and contributors. Results of longitudinal network analysis on four layers of comment networks present nuanced interaction patterns such as reciprocity, inertia, and homophily. Results suggest that active contribution tends to receive fair returns from the community. Pairs of ideators tend to share reciprocated comments, regardless of the comment types. Therefore, to gain substantial information, ideators should take the initiative and contribute substantially to peer competitors. Moreover, ideators tend to maintain existing habits of comment-giving. Ideators with similar ideas share coopetitive relationships through both cooperative and self-interested comments.

Creative Commons License

Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 4.0 International License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 4.0 International License.

Link to Full Text

Share

COinS