Go to main content

The central question surrounding this thesis is whether or not United States’ federal courts are balancing the issue of national security threats against the issue of public interest when dealing with whistleblower cases. The first step it takes in answering this question is examining whistleblowers under John Rawls’ standard of justified acts of civil disobedience. Afterwards, the research examines how the respective courts look at the act of leaking causing a potential security threat or its benefit to the public interest. This analysis is performed by using the Inter-American Court of Human Rights’ structure for dealing with free speech issues as a guide. The whistleblowers that are examined are the following: Daniel Ellsberg, Thomas Andrews Drake, John Kiriakou, Chelsea Manning, and Edward Snowden. Finally, the research concludes by examining the results, applying the results to what it would mean for the case of Snowden, and ultimately what it would mean for whistleblower cases at large.